There should be a final vote, since if Cyzir doesn't make it, we would all most likely vote for yDG
I'm going to take issue with this. Both pokemon look very much like a rock type. I think you are being a bit too myopic when you look at the word rock type. That does not necessarily have to be a direct relation to rock. The Rock type pokemon are basically a conglomerate of geological features. There is plenty of precedent for rock types that are not made of rocks. (Rhydon, Aerodactyl, Sudowoodo, Corsola, Tyranitar, Cradily, etc.) However, all rock pokemon have a geological essence about them, and you can see them relating to rocks in a way. Art is a very subjective process. It isn't going to be extremely straightforward.2. It should look like a pure Rock type.
yDG's you can see the Rock element straight away in the floating stones that make up all of its body, many argue that it also looks part steel. I can see what they mean but you do get gray rock as well as brown. The body parts are just made of polished gray stone.
Cala.. Really other than the floating rocks and brown colour I do not see much Rock about it. It looks like a Psychic/something... In the vertion with cracks I could see the rock typing, but the one that is in the poll... not so much.
As it is it could be part Rock but Psychic looks more evident, largely due to the glowing green lines all over its body....
i second thisyourDeadGandad from start to finish!
all the rock types you just mentioned also have a second type though, except sudowoodoThere is plenty of precedent for rock types that are not made of rocks. (Rhydon, Aerodactyl, Sudowoodo, Corsola, Tyranitar, Cradily, etc.) However, all rock pokemon have a geological essence about them, and you can see them relating to rocks in a way.
i second this
all the rock types you just mentioned also have a second type though...
Not really.Sudowoodo
That's because the whole point of Sudowoodo is to look like wood...Not really.
Then again, Sudowoodo does not look like a Rock-type at all.
...wow, I just noticed the only pure Rock types that look like rocks are Nosepass and Regirock. Sudowoodo is a tree and Rampardos is a revived fossil.
sez who?? this was the last poll anyways, and caladbolg just won! yea calad!!There should be a final vote, since if Cyzir doesn't make it, we would all most likely vote for yDG