Smeargle's super underrated in general. Really, all of my effective teams so far in RU have been utilizing the fact that Smeargle essentially takes out a mon with Spore and gets up at least one layer of hazards if I play it right.I don't get why smeargle isn't being used. It has access to spore and has the ability to either set up hazards or baton pass out of there.
im assuming you mean regular rotom. There are alot of things that can come in and set up on claydol (if it doesn't toxic on the switch) such as bulk up gallade,krook,hunchkrow, etc. Rotom is a big threat though as it can wilo-wisp on the incoming krook and the ability to 2hko most of the tier^ I agree with Amarilo
everyone should use rotom-O with Claydol being the number 1 ranked pokemon in the Tier, Rotom-O pretty much counters it most of the time, with the exception of Claydol carrying Shadow ball or switching into a predicted Toxic.
I personally prefer Toxic on my Claydol to catch Mummy and Dusknoir on the switch. Although I've been seeing more Mummy's with Rest, but since it doesn't have sleep talk, it's a sitting duck unless your team carries a Cleric.
I lost to Endeavour hail as well but that was because I didn't expect it and my Rotom Died early in the battle.
Ah well...
Claydol is #1 for the overall metagame. For the users above a 1200, you can see how less useful it is. I guess its used because it is defensive in both defense and special unlike other spinners such as hitmonchan and Kabutops. It also can hurt quilfish which is the poke that puts up hazards the most. But still, claydol is set up fodder for alot of pokes. This tier is centered on dark,bug, and grass pokemon which provokes its walling abilitiesI still have no idea why Claydol is #1 after all this time... it's an awful Pokemon in the current metagame. It basically sets up Stealth Rock, and...that's it. It can't spin at all if your opponent has a decent Ghost-type. Seriously, all the Ghost-types in the teir shit all over Claydol. It's not even that good as a tank, most powerful attackers will 2HKO with SR support or just a bit of prior damage, not to mention that most sweepers carry a coverage move that is effective against Claydol. Bulky setup users like Gallade and Poliwrath also set up all over it while Claydol can't phaze them. Honchkrow just laughs at it if it doesn't have Ice Beam, while Lilligant sets up on it regardless even with the Sleep Clause in play. Blizzspam teams basically make it worthless because it can't switch in and it's slower than even the slowest Specs abusers, even Specs Glaceon is faster than a no-investment Claydol. That means that, of the three biggest threats in the teir, Claydol is fairly useless against... all of them.
Congrats on making RU council. Yes, Sharpedo requires heavy team support. It cannot come in most neutral hits or even resisted hits from the likes of Slowing because of its rash nature. I don't see porygon-z used alot though. It is a good poke nonetheless but I believe it's not appealing to people because of its typing and its average defenses.Cannot even comprehend how I got picked for the council right now (as best forum poster no less!). It's 12:35 and I should be writing my paper for my lit final that's due tomorrow.
As for Sharpedo, having gotten onto the first ranking page with two seperate alts using Sharpedo, I can account for the fact that it has several issues that prevent it from being a suspect. First off is that priority is automatic doom for Sharpedo. Second is that it's very easy to predict either an attack or a Protect for the first move depending on the player's playstyle (part of my success with Sharpedo is my unpredictability). Third is that Sharpedo requires either heavy team support or a lot of weakening of the opposing team to be effective (the mixed set at least). Fourth, Sharpedo is utterly neutered by Thunder Wave, which is absolutely ubiquitous in RU. If you don't find at least one T-Wave user on a team, it's a surprise. Fifth, is that the premier Walls/tanks like Cofagrigus and Uxie are much harder to KO than they should be if you run Crunch (which you should be doing, Hydro Pump is easily a thousand times better than Surf, which Dark Pulse limits you to), and they can either cripple you with status or hit you with a Super-effective attack and do heavy damage. The last is that it has a bona-fide counter in Poliwrath. Pity Zen Headbutt is off limits for Speed Boost Sharpedo.
Anyway, Porygon-Z is apparently our suspect. Well, believe it or not, I got to the first page with him too. Tbh, it wasn't as monsterous as I expected. It has surprisingly little utility for something with four on-site sets and a wide movepool.
Hitmonlee only servers as a check for both of them. He won't live 2 hydro pumps or 2 tri attacks. But like you said I don't seem to have a major problem with them. Most of them are scarfs so I can predict. Or I can sack one mon, then set up with another that resists that move. The sub variants are more trouble for me than scarfs.Munchlax is the only one to counter it at the moment. Porygon-z has amazing coverage but it doesn't have enough speed to compliment thatHonestly, I haven't found P-Z or Sharpedo to be that dangerous at all. it seems like there are plenty of bulky fighting pokemons that easily kill them. unburden hitmonlee in particular seems to dominate both of them. he uses the speed boost to easily outspeed even scarf variants of P-Z and uses mach punch to kill sharpedo.