-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Paranoia Mafia Game Over - Mafia Wins
- Thread starter Andy Snype
- Start date
- Status
I'd say 2 maybe 3 but unlikely.
To be fair though if we let to many villagers die before we find the terrorists there will be a problem. Considering we need to both find terrorists and preserve town, no-lynching might be a great way to let power roles get information.
I know people dont like set-up speculation but I dont think it would make sense to have this ruleset without investigative roles to help town narrow down scum as quickly as possible.
I'm for a day 1 no-lynch for now.
"Terrorists win if at least one terrorist is alive when the living players vote to end the game or if a significant (but predetermined amount known to the terrorists) proportion of the villagers are dead."
Quoted from rules of initial post.
Setup spec is fucking useless
Unvote Lynch Shubaka17
Normally I might agree, but not for this game. Really this game seems like it's all about set up speculations to the point of being able to determine when there are no longer any scum. I mean, there's reasons why the rules are written in a way to include the possibility of no scum at all.
No in this game determining scum has nothing to do with setup spec, and in any case scum are just going to play on any assumptions anyway. Say Day 1 we collectively agree to stop at 3 terrorist flips or some shit, it sets the tone for their strategy while keeping us rigid. Such agreements are difficult anyway, and I encourage people to simply have their wits about them and keep an open mind.
This game is about looking at people, which reminds me: BEING ACTIVE IN THIS GAME IS EVEN MORE IMPORTANT THAN IN STANDARD GAMES. This is because Cops, Vig Shots, and Process of Elimination are not tools that we have. You don't have a PR to hide, this is explicitly anti town play, so I will be cracking down on it.
Fuck no lynch. We don't let the scum wash their hands of this day accountability wise, and the case where it helps even a little bit is so slim it's not worth the bet.
I swear everytime I try to end setup spec it just keeps going I should really stop doing that.
This game is about looking at people, which reminds me: BEING ACTIVE IN THIS GAME IS EVEN MORE IMPORTANT THAN IN STANDARD GAMES. This is because Cops, Vig Shots, and Process of Elimination are not tools that we have. You don't have a PR to hide, this is explicitly anti town play, so I will be cracking down on it.
Dentricos here shows a lack of understanding that all townies are the same. You can quote the rules at me but I assure you I understand them. This is paranoia mafia. We don't have shit to help us gain info. In this specific situation I'm willing to call that a town > scum slip for now because if he honestly believed that we had cops then he would be playing differently as scum.
Fuck no lynch. We don't let the scum wash their hands of this day accountability wise, and the case where it helps even a little bit is so slim it's not worth the bet.
I swear everytime I try to end setup spec it just keeps going I should really stop doing that.
Blazade's points are correct imo
Unlynch Vote Hawkie
Unlynch Vote Hawkie
blazade is 100% correct
optimal town play is to lynch based off scum behavior until we're reasonably convinced there are no more scum
willing to toss a slight townlean on blazade for protown logic; the "slight" is because blazade's smart enough to replicate it as scum, i just don't know if he decides to do so
optimal town play is to lynch based off scum behavior until we're reasonably convinced there are no more scum
willing to toss a slight townlean on blazade for protown logic; the "slight" is because blazade's smart enough to replicate it as scum, i just don't know if he decides to do so
Random Voting Stage
people tossing out random votes at the very start of the game in an attempt to generate discussion
i don't like analyzing anything that happens before the actual discussion is generated because the votes are usually just jokey and meaningless
people tossing out random votes at the very start of the game in an attempt to generate discussion
i don't like analyzing anything that happens before the actual discussion is generated because the votes are usually just jokey and meaningless
Quick question is there ever a reason for village to end game? It seems like village can just play till the last player because there's zero reason to ever end game since we only win if all terrorists are dead anyways and there's no risk till waiting for the end unless I'm missing something important
Walrein is slightly towny to me for the same reasoning he's applying to blazade
- Status