Damnit, I am defeated.
Anyway, Nightmare Jigglypuff is P2 because of MUDS. Nachos has effectively ruined my streak of "naw, you're P2"
What a dick ;_;
Speaking of P2, actually. In case you haven't noticed, the Standard limit of 25 players has already been more than met by the P1s. So if you're currently not P1 (read: if you're playing in MUDS), then you're welcome to list yourself as a potential sub, but there's no chance of you getting in anymore. Sorry, guys.
Anyway, since there are already a whole mess of signups, I'm going to just go ahead and start this game some time tonight, closer to the 24 hour mark. That gives any additional P1 players ~7 hours from now to sign up from the time this was posted.