I don't know. Whats this evidence that you have against Gormenghast, Shiv? I don't want to waste my vote on a bandwagon.
QFT.
Also, Obi was one of the loudest people and turned out to be a Death Eater. He also said he had a mole-style role which would be clean upon inspection. How are we to know Shiv is not the same?
Of course, he's managed to organise a lot of the villagers with his supposed hint, but again who's to say he didn't get extra information above other members of a mafia group. Now he's attempting to vote gorm on from what I see very little evidence.
He has gathered a lot of trust from the students based on one small tidbit from a PM, and seems to be the most informed person here. Perhaps too well informed. Notice how the first night only Death Eaters died? It would be logical to conclude that Shiv is Ministry, and has organised the villagers to take one group out first, then with all the knowledge he has, can eliminate enough key roles on the student side to win.
Of course, Shiv will claim his innocence, as regular players of mafia know, he always does until the last possible moment, and is very convincing. He also takes the slightest bit of information and is able to use it to his advantage. As in this case, his hint to the students could very well come from an informed mole who recieved extra information to effectively seal his role.
I'll post my vote in a bit, but I wanted to get this out the way before I'm targeted by Shiv's bandwagons (he already has it in for me).
Rule #1 of Mafia - Never Trust Shiv